Fermentation, Histamine & OAT
- 4 hours ago
- 3 min read
Why Nourishing Foods Can Suddenly Feel Like the Enemy
Fermentation, Histamine & OAT
Why Nourishing Foods Can Suddenly Feel Like the Enemy
I see this a lot: fermented foods once helped, and then one day they suddenly seem to make everything worse. If that’s you, you’re not failing, or “doing it wrong”. You’re also not obliged to choose between two exhausting extremes: ferment everything forever, or fear almost everything you eat.
Many people arrive in my practice feeling itchy, bloated, constipated, or running to the loo, wired, foggy, with aching joints and a growing sense that food has become a bit of an enemy. Often they’re baffled, because they’ve done all the “right” things, eaten well, avoided junk, added ferments for gut health, and somehow ended up feeling worse.
There is a reason this happens, and it isn’t moral failure, weak digestion, or lifelong intolerance.
Fermentation is potent food, not neutral food
Fermented foods are powerful, wonderfully so, and sometimes a bit unforgiving. That’s their gift, and also their catch. When we ferment foods, it increases their biological activity, concentrating microbial signalling, organic acids, enzymes, and biogenic amines, including histamine. This is why ferments can be deeply restorative for some people and abruptly inflammatory for others.
The trouble starts when we treat fermentation as a cure-all rather than what it really is: a timing-dependent tool.
Fermented foods ask something of the body: clearance capacity, mineral sufficiency, enzymatic readiness, and a nervous system that isn’t already running on high alert. When those systems are under strain, ferments can simply be too much, too fast.
That doesn’t make fermentation “bad”. It just means the system receiving it is overwhelmed.
Histamine is a signal of capacity, not an identity
Histamine reactions are often framed as a permanent label: histamine intolerance. That label tends to trap people in fear and long-term restriction.
I believe that a more helpful way is to look at histamine reactions as as a capacity signal.
Histamine plays many useful roles in the body, from digestion and immunity to neurotransmission and tissue repair. Problems arise when production outpaces clearance, or when regulation is already strained. This can happen for all sorts of reasons, including mineral imbalance, gut dysbiosis, nutrient depletion, chronic stress, or simple cumulative overload.
When capacity is exceeded, foods that were once tolerated can suddenly provoke symptoms. That doesn’t mean those foods are inherently wrong for you forever, it means your system can’t process them right now.
This distinction matters, because capacity can change; and I see that shift happen more often than people expect.
What is an OAT, where it fits, and where it doesn’t
People ask me frequently if an Organic Acids Test (OAT) can diagnose histamine intolerance. What it can do is help us stop guessing.
An OAT doesn’t look for histamine itself. Instead, it shows how well your body is coping behind the scenes. Is your gut producing a lot of irritating by-products? Are you struggling to make energy? Are certain foods not being used properly? Are your detox and clearance pathways overloaded?
When someone has histamine-type symptoms, those background pressures are often what tip the system over the edge. The OAT helps us see which pressures are present, and which aren’t. That means we can focus on the real drivers, rather than blaming every food, cutting things out unnecessarily, or throwing supplements at the wall to see what sticks.
In other words, it helps explain why your body is reacting — and just as importantly, what probably isn’t the problem.
Used well, an OAT helps answer:
what needs stabilising first,
what can wait,
and what might be better reintroduced later rather than forced now.
It’s a guide, not a judge.
A calm way forward
If you’re caught between conflicting advice, reacting to foods that are meant to be nourishing, or staring at test results without a clear sense of what to do next, you don’t need another list of forbidden foods, you need a bit of hand-holding to make sense of it all.
I offer a focused orientation consultation for people navigating histamine-type symptoms, food reactions, and test results such as OATs. This is not about protocols or perfection, it's about making sense of your terrain and restoring choice, step by step.
If that sounds like what you’re looking for, let's explore working together.
Next step
A 90-minute session focused on making sense of histamine-type symptoms — the itchy, foggy, wired, reactive kind — and deciding what actually helps next.
Comments